the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Using an Airborne Wind Energy System as a turbulence sensor
Abstract. Atmospheric turbulence characterisation in the upper atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) remains a challenge, as conventional measurement techniques, such as masts and lidars, have fundamental limitations at those altitudes. Airborne Wind Energy Systems (AWES), which operate tethered kites at altitudes beyond the surface-layer, show great promise as turbulence sensing platforms. This paper describes a methodology to characterise atmospheric turbulence from quantities that are available from standard onboard sensors. The methodology has been developed in UniSimAWE, Kitemill's in-house simulator framework, where the Mann model has been employed to generate atmospheric turbulence. The two operational phases of ground generation AWES, production and return phase, have been exploited as complementary sampling strategies. During the return phase, the kite follows a near-streamwise trajectory, enabling measurement of the turbulence intensity and integral time and length scales for the three velocity components. Moreover, Taylor's frozen turbulence hypothesis has been shown to hold for this sampling strategy, both through the integral length-to-time scale ratio, and the wavenumber-to-frequency power spectral density ratio. In the production phase, the kite flies in crosswind manoeuvres, following a helical path; the dominant crosswind component allows measurement of the integral time and length scales in the crosswind direction which are unavailable from conventional fixed-point sensors. In addition, the helical path enables the measurement of streamwise integral time scale. A novel time scale is introduced to characterise the interaction between the atmospheric turbulent structures and the AWES trajectory, with relevance for turbulence-adaptive control. The results demonstrate the potential of AWES to measure relevant atmospheric turbulence quantities throughout its operation, with advantages over conventional measurement techniques.
- Preprint
(3710 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
CC1: 'Comment on wes-2026-150', Duc Nguyen, 30 Sep 2026
-
CC2: 'Reply on CC1', Duc Nguyen, 30 Sep 2026
Publisher’s note: the content of this comment was removed on 2 October 2026 since the comment was posted by mistake.
Disclaimer: this community comment is written by an individual and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of their employer.Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/wes-2026-150-CC2
-
CC2: 'Reply on CC1', Duc Nguyen, 30 Sep 2026
-
RC1: 'Comment on wes-2026-150', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 Oct 2026
This study presents a novel method to characterise turbulence using an airborne wind energy system as a sensor. The methodology is demonstrated with data from an in-house simulator that combines a rigid-body kite model and a lumped-mass tether model with Kitemill’s own flight controller and path planner. The inflow is a uniform (shear-free) wind profile, with turbulence generated using the Mann model. Sensor measurements are assumed to be exact, so the wind measured at the kite represents a best-case reconstruction.
Overall, the paper demonstrates the methodology for obtaining relevant turbulence characteristics from measurements of the flow where the kite flies, under highly idealised inflow and velocity-reconstruction conditions. The idea is novel and relevant, and it could form a useful basis for follow-up studies that use the kite as an inflow sensor. The idealised sensor measurements provide a clean identification of which turbulence characteristics can be obtained from measurements along the kite trajectory alone. However, given the idealised sensor and inflow assumptions, the authors should be careful in drawing conclusions about applicability until the method is tested with experimental data, or at least with added sensor noise and uncertainty.
GENERAL COMMENTS
1.In the introduction (lines 32–40), you present previous studies that use the kite as an inflow sensor, noting that they do not focus on turbulence, whereas this study does. As I understand it, those sensor-fusion studies aim to estimate the wind speed, which can then be used to derive turbulence metrics. In other words, they provide the input that a realistic version of the present study would require. In addition, one of the cited studies (Cayon, 2025) includes a comparison of some turbulence metrics against lidar estimates. I would therefore suggest revising how these studies are positioned, presenting them as complementary to, or a prerequisite for, the present work rather than as not addressing turbulence.
2. The wind measurements are obtained from a v_a sensor and a v_k sensor. Does this yield the same wind speed as sampling the flow field directly? If so, could you explain why? If not, please state this explicitly. If they are different Figure 9 should include both.
3. For this method to be applied in practice, an important element is missing: a methodology for estimating the mean wind as a function of height from kite data. The authors acknowledge the shear simplification in the current simulated data in relation to Eq. 5, but no method for estimating the mean profile in practice is given. A general approach should be added, including a justification of the averaging timescales and height binning, and a discussion of how errors in the estimated mean would affect the turbulence characteristics. I consider this the main point requiring revision.
4. In line 207 and elsewhere, you state that the frozen-turbulence assumption is validated. Correct me if I am wrong, but is the Mann model not itself built on this assumption? If so, this would be a consistency check or verification rather than a validation.
5. The conclusions state that an AWES can serve as an effective atmospheric turbulence sensor. Is this conclusion generalisable? I think sensor noise and uncertainty should at least be accounted for before making such a statement. Showing that relevant turbulence characteristics can be obtained from measurements along the kite trajectory alone is already a valuable result, but broader generalisations should be made carefully until the method is validated with operational data.
SPECIFIC COMMENTS
1. L156: You mention a lidar dataset. Is this dataset publicly available, or will it be made available? It could be a valuable contribution to the AWES research community.
2. L200: The expression “w_i = 1/i” at the end of the sentence appears to be a leftover and should be removed.
3. L222: Could you specify the turbulence box sizes used? Do they change with the length scale?
4. Eq. 11: There is a negative logarithm in the integral. Please check that the equation is correct.
RECOMMENDATION
Overall, I recommend this paper for publication after revision. It presents a novel methodology that is directly relevant to the development of AWES technology. Before publication, however, one major point should be addressed: General comment 3 on the estimation of the mean wind with height. The remaining general and specific comments are minor and mainly concern clarifications and more carefully tempered wording.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/wes-2026-150-RC1 -
RC2: 'Comment on wes-2026-150', Anonymous Referee #2, 29 Oct 2026
The manuscript describes the development of a theoretical and conceptual framework that might in the future allow to use Airborne Wind Energy Systems (AWES) equipped with a multi-hole probe for flow measurements to determine/estimate different turbulence parameters (turbulence intensity and integral time and length scales for the three velocity components) during the two operational phases of an AWES. Corresponding measurements would provide important and beneficial complementary information to, e.g. lidar remote sensing, at altitudes that are not accessible by meteorological masts. It presents an interesting idea for the advancement of our ABL observational capabilities and fits into the scope of WES. The manuscript is clearly structured, would, however, language-wise in many places benefit from an overhaul by a native speaker, as it contains several strange and hard to read grammatical constructs (some, but not all of them are also specified in the minor comment section) or a bit un-scientific wording that has to be improved.
Overall we see the potential for publication of the manuscript after major revision.GENERAL COMMENTS
-
the title is misleading, promising something you are not delivering! You can use it as soon as you have shown that it works with real measurements from your system in air! I strongly recommend to change to e,g.: "Can AWES be used as turbulence sensor?" That goes together with line 355/356, the first sentence of the conclusions, giving a very bold statement ("This work demonstrates that an Airborne Wind Energy System (AWES) can serve as an effective atmospheric turbulence sensor") which I only can (and will) buy if you have shown that it also works with real kite-based measurements instead of only the simulations! Especially in the context if the limitations and assumptions you assess throughout the paper (l.120ff: the relevant parameters measurable by the onboard sensor are known (kite velocity, apparent wind velocity, kite attitude); l.130ff: shear is not taken into account). What I have learned from the manuscript and I could agree upon is "This work indicates that AWES might have the potential to serve as atmospheric turbulence sensor"
-
line 24/25: the discussion of the problematic of turbulence determination by lidar is very limited and incomplete. I suggest to extend that considerably and to include more recent literature in the field, which is at the moment rather active; and you also pick this up as one of the main arguments in your conclusion (l.401ff) where you mention that AWES outperform lidardue to their smaller spatial and temporal resolution.
-
Fig. 3 and corresponding discussion: where is your hypothetical sensor for the ambient flow measurement placed? In the center of gravity/motion of your Kitemill modell in the simulations, or at the wingtip/nose of the system as it would be placed for real measurements. In your sketch it looks like you use just the center of mass, which would in turn mean that you have additional effects on the multi-hole probe measurements to consider that are related to the pitch and yaw motions of the aircraft, depending on the distance between flow sensor and center of mass
-
How was the length scale for the Mann-Modell derived, I would like to see a bit more on that. My main concern is that your operation height of 300 m is at the altitude limit for the lidar (which I assume is a ZX300 continuous-wave lidar) with very poor resolution at those altitudes, potentially creating uncertainties by extrapolation; So I am wondering why the authors have not utilized the available 2-year lidar wind profiler data set from Lista collected with a WLS-7 pulsed lidar as collaboration between DTU Wind Energy and the University of Bergen. I assume one fixed value for LMM is not really realistic and it would be great to see some statistics/distributions to estimate its representativeness.
-
Determination of the integral time and length scales (Figs 10 and 11 and explaining text)
There has to be more information on how exactly you performed the exponential fit for the determination of the length scales? Over which time interval did you fit? Looks a bit arbitrarily here when, e.g., comparing the solid and dashed lines. I would like to see objective criteria here you have chosen, as at the moment the whole method and description feels rather subjective. Without any clear objective criteria it looks to me like "cherry-picking" to come to the values that allow for your "verification" of the validity/applicability of Taylor's Hypothesis. -
in general, for all figures a more detailed caption would improve the understanding of the paper and the methods you applied, so the reader can understand the main points without having to go through the text and search for the specific section and paragraph
SPECIFIC COMMENTS
- line 17: "with advantages over conventional measurement techniques.": this statement is disputable.... you can convince me by showing that your proposed method will work with real in-flight measurement data
- l.23ff: lidar potential discussion is pretty vague/ generic; in which terms do lidar systems support here?; also you mention 'multiple mechanisms' in l.27: mention maybe one of them
- line 26: "to the increasing size of averaging volume with height"; this is only an issue for cw-lidar systems, not for pulsed ones
- line 27: "uncertainties emerge due to multiple mechanisms"; please name/list those mechanisms together with relevant references
- l.41ff: the sentence is kind of weird formulated; also: what is the conventional height range of a wind turbine you are talking about?
- l.45: you mention the kitemill concept, but how do you exactly plan to apply this? is this just future plan? if so, state this directly or in the outlook
- line 46: "rigid kite" is this an AWES specific terminology? For me it would be more a "tethered aircraft", but maybe that term would cause issues with respect to the aviation authorities?
- line 63/54: "ground-genrigid AWES," looks like that there is something missing
- l.74: you mention PID, would be nice to introduce the abbreviation first
- line 85: "referred to as "turbulence boxes" and are generated using the Hipersim tool": I assume (but can't find any information) that those boxes are calculated for neutral atmospheric conditions? Or has Hipersim the possibility to include stability. In any case that should be stated more clearly here
- l.85: use a consistent citation style in the paper
- line 90: "convected" is typically used for the vertical component; I suggest to use "advected" instead
- Fig. 2: this figure indicates an inherent wind shear! with lower average wind speeds at higher altitudes (blue color); I assume you would see a low-level jet like structure when averaging that plot over time
- line 95: "The first step to obtain the turbulence fluctuations sensed by the kite is to measure the wind velocity vector": This sentence misleads to believe that there are real measurements involved, which is clearly not the case. Thus, you should formulate more carefully, e.g. as "to estimate" or "to determine"
- l.113: the rotation matrix and the derivation from the source is behind a paywall and i cannot access this; it would be nice to at least put the relevant steps in the appendix so that i as a reader have the chance to understand the different steps
- line 118: "resuling on:" should read "resulting in:"
- l.129f: sentence is a bit off
- l.148f: what would be a representative frame then?/ what do you have to do to make it representative?
- line 161: "Γ = 3.0, per the (neutral)" that reads strange, is there something missing? and based on what can we assume neutral conditions here?
- line 190: "but it distorts visual area because": strange expression/wording; please rephrase and explain a bit more in detail what you want to say here
- l.190-195: i had to read this paragraph several times to understand what is happening, the reader really has to work to get to the core, maybe this can be redone
- caption Fig. 19: "10m"; use blank between numbers and units; please check throughout the whole document
- line 245: "allows us to infer at what frequencies there is a more variance": grammatically strange construct, please rephrase
- Fig A1: do you have an explanation for the energy loss around 2Hz in the streamwise component? There is no corresponding signal in the other two components
- Fig B1: axes labels by far too small; maybe also increase font size of the legend a bit
- line 455 (symbols/abbreviations): rho/ACF: it makes in my eyes no sense to have both an abbreviation and a symbol! Gets confusing when reading the corresponding text passages; I suggest to chose one throughout the work.
- references
- line 502: journal name should be upper case
- line 513/514: upper case issues in both title and journal name
- line 529: journal name should be upper case
- line 535: journal should read "Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences"
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/wes-2026-150-RC2 -
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 563 | 178 | 59 | 800 | 72 | 69 |
- HTML: 563
- PDF: 178
- XML: 59
- Total: 800
- BibTeX: 72
- EndNote: 69
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
Publisher’s note: the content of this comment was removed on 2 October 2026 since the comment was posted by mistake.