Thank you for a most elaborate and interesting defense of your manuscript. I agree with your notion that this instability of the controller of one of the most used wind turbine models deserves some attention, and your manuscript seems to nicely analyze the issue, as well as proposing alternatives and further insights.

I therefore recommend your work for publication and hereby invite you to prepare a revised manuscript along the lines indicated in your answers to the reviewer comments.

I agree with the editor and with your well-formulated reply that this paper should be published after the revision you propose. The intension with the journal is indeed to promote critical, scientific dialogue.

Jakob Mann, Editor-in-Chief